Defendant's Discovery

Discovery is the pre-trial phase in a lawsuit in which the plaintiff and defendant, through the law of civil procedure, can request documents and other evidence from other parties or can compel the production of evidence by using a subpoena or through other discovery devices, such as depositions upon oral examination or written questions; written interrogatories; production of documents or things or permission to enter upon land or other property for inspection and other purposes; physical and mental examinations; and requests for admission. The frequency of use of the above methods may be limited by your states law of civil procedure. Florida law states:

Parties may obtain discovery regarding any matter, not privileged, that is relevant to the subject matter of the pending action, whether it relates to the claim or defense of the party seeking discovery or the claim or defense of any other party, including the existence, description, nature, custody, condition, and location of any books, documents, or other tangible things and the identity and location of persons having knowledge of any discoverable matter. It is not ground for objection that the information sought will be inadmissible at the trial if the information sought appears reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.

You may find out that the debt collection attorney may not be forthcoming in providing you with the documents that you requested; for example, if you request the original signed contract or application for credit, the debt collection attorney may object, stating that the document is irrelevant to the case. In this case, you'll have to file a motion to compel. Also, small claims court is usually more relax when it comes to Discovery. Discovery is your chance to find out what supporting evidence the Plaintiff has in their possession; most likely, the only evidence the debt collection attorney has is a printout of alleged charges. Listed below is an example of what you might send the debt collection attorney in terms of Discovery. Sample Discovery Court Form. Always file original requests with the Clerk of Court and send copies to the debt collection attorney; keep a copy for yourself.

REQUEST TO PRODUCE

 

  1. All invoices created by the Plaintiff.

 

  1. All statements created by the Plaintiff.

 

  1. All cancelled checks evidencing payments by Defendant to the Plaintiff on the account in suit.

 

  1. All contracts, agreements and memoranda of agreements between the parties.

 

  1. All correspondence received by the Plaintiff from the Defendant.

 

  1. All correspondence sent by the Plaintiff to the Defendant.

 

  1. Plaintiff's entire file concerning the matter which is herein in controversy.

 

  1. Plaintiff's account payable ledger or book or record, kept in the usual course of Plaintiff's business, pertaining to the account of Defendant with Plaintiff.

 

  1. Any written objections sent by Plaintiff to Defendant claiming objections to the payments to the account.

 

  1. Any written notification sent by Plaintiff to Defendant claiming any objections to the payments to the account.

 

  1. All documents identified in the Interrogatories filed with this Request to Produce.

 

  1. All documents which would evidence why Defendant(s) failed to pay the debt as alleged in the Complaint.

 

  1. All documents evidencing that Defendant(s) owes the money alleged in Plaintiff's Complaint.

 

  1. All documents evidencing payments made by Defendant(s) on this account.

 

REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS

 

  1. You have no signed contract or signed application for credit which shows the Defendant applied for a Credit Card.

 

  1. You have no signed contract or signed application for credit showing that an account was established in the Defendant's name and a Credit Card was issued to the Defendant.

 

  1. You have no written contract entitled Cardmember Agreement that states the terms and conditions that the Defendant agreed to.

 

  1. You have no written and signed contract stating the Defendant would be responsible for all charges made on the account in connection with all Credit Cards issued on the account.

 

  1. You have no merchant receipts showing the charges that were incurred on the account in the sum of $X.


NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES

 

  1. Please state the name, business and home addresses and telephone numbers, of the persons answering these interrogatories.

 

  1. If you claim that the charges billed are correct please state, with particularity, how such charges are calculated.

 

  1. Please list each person known to you or to your attorney who has personal knowledge of the matters involved in this lawsuit, and as to each, please state their name, home and business addresses and telephone numbers, and relationship to the Plaintiff(s), if any.

 

  1. State the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of each person who you intend to call as a witness at the trial of this case, and provide a brief synopsis as to the anticipated testimony of each.

 

  1. State the name of the person or employee of Plaintiff who is responsible for the generation of invoices and statements.

 

  1. State the name and address of the person who is the records custodian of the books and records of Plaintiff.

 

  1. With reference to each and every claim you have stated, state the factual basis for your claim, identify all persons who have knowledge of the facts supporting the claim and state the date and description of any documents which would support the claim.  

Similar Results

100.00%1.Trademark v A&E Update - July 2008 - It has been some time since I last updated you on the status of the Trademark vs A&E litigation taking place in the US District Court in Charleston, SC.  During this time, discovery has been taking place, with Judge Houck offering reasonable extensions of deadlines for the parties.  A&E expressed difficulty in obtaining discovery from Trademark, [...] - 7/13/2008. Flip This Lawsuit
67.45%2.Why purchasing debt is a bad bet at trial - A recent speaker at the Michigan Institute of Continuing Legal Education had talked about suing on purchased debt. He said that a debt buyer does not have to produce a witness from the originating creditor in order to prove his... - 8/20/2008. Michigan Collection Law Blog
63.29%3.Why suing on purchased debt is rarely successful. - A recent speaker at the Michigan Institute of Continuing Legal Education had talked about suing on purchased debt. He said that a debt buyer does not have to produce a witness from the originating creditor in order to prove his... - 8/30/2008. Michigan Collection Law Blog
57.02%4.Trademark v A&E Moving Slowly - As often happens in litigation, the Trademark Properties lawsuit is moving along slowly.  On July 17, the Court set a number of deadlines: Plaintiffs ID of Expert Witness due by 9/13/2007 Defendants ID of Expert Witnesses Due by 10/13/2007 Amended Pleadings due by 11/13/2007 Discovery due by 11/13/2007 Motions due by 12/13/2007 Jury Selection Deadline 2/13/2008 The docket doesn’t reflect any filings that [...] - 10/25/2007. Flip This Lawsuit
54.91%5.The only website to obtain all 3 credit reports for free every year - Remember, there is only one true website to obtain your yearly 3 free credit reports! You can request your reports online here, or you can download and print this form if you feel more comfortable mailing your request form to receive your free reports.

Here is the address where you send the form to obtain ALL reports, including:
Experian, TransUnion and Equifax:
- 10/22/2008. Jeff's Blog
54.58%6.Can a debt collector request and cash a post-dated check? - - 7/8/2008. Jeff's Blog
40.55%7.Examples of Scams - IRS Economic Stimulus Refund - This scam appears to be from the IRS informing the receipiant that they are entitled to either a bonus tax refund or extra money from the economic stimulus program. They request that the receipiant send them personal information in order to recieve the check. - 12/5/2008. Identity Theft Resource Center
27.29%8. - Can you use your credit cards when your on a credit counseling program?
As part of the mutual agreement between the creditors and the client, the client is required to stop using the credit cards. Acquiring more debt while on a debt consolidation program defeats the purpose of being on the program in the first place. If creditors are willing to give more favorable repayment benefits to a client they want to make sure that they can not charge any more debt - 10/26/2007. Kimbery Credit Counselings Blog
25.93%9.Subject: Thanks and GOD bless you - - 1/5/2009. 419 Legal - Internet Fraud and Online Scam Forum
23.72%10.10 THINGS DEBT COLLECTORS DO NOT WANT YOU TO KNOW!! -

  1. Debt collection letters received after filing Bankruptcy may have violated the automatic stay or discharge injunction and you may have the right to recover money!

  2. When leaving a message, a debt collector MUST disclose that he/she is a debt collector. If this information is not disclosed, you may have the right to recover money!

  3. Even though debt collectors are permitted to attempt to collect a debt after its been in default for 4 years, they are NOT permitted to take legal action against you, nor are they permitted to threaten you with
- 4/23/2007. Jeff's Blog
22.54%11. - Cost That Are Associated With Credit Cards?

Interest - This is added to your credit card balance and is usually approximately 18.9% and may and may be compounded on a daily basis against the balance that you carry on your credit card. Interest is how credit card issuers make money. Interest is alos what makes up the finance charge.

Annual fees - Some credit card issuers charge these fees sometimes up to $75 or more, to your account each year. These fees are sometime call
- 11/7/2007. Kimbery Credit Counselings Blog
21.73%12.Facts for Pittsburgh Consumers About Your Credit Report - SCAMS

Nationwide, companies promise Pittsburgh consumers (for a steep fee of course) to clean up your credit report to improve your score. Nine times out of ten, they can't deliver and vanish with your money.

SOME WARNING SIGNS OF THE SCAM:
- 4/30/2008. Jeff's Blog
19.00%13.A Need to Know Debt Collection Tactic to Harass and Threaten you into paying an Old Debt - A debt collection tactic that FDCPA attorney, Jeff Suher wants you to know about!!

O.K., debt collectors can be sleazy - but this tactic is one that takes the cake.
Let me simply put a scenario together for you.....

A debt collector contacts a consumer about an old debt and requests thousands of dollars, as they often do. A lot of times the consumer cannot afford to pay a lump sum of thousands of dollars and will request monthly payments.

- 6/11/2008. Jeff's Blog
15.98%14. - Credit Repair - Truth about it

Credit Repair BEWARE! There are numerous companies throughout the United States that claim they can “fix” your credit reports for a fee. In most cases they do little or nothing to fix your credit reports. What ends up happening is these companies take your money and disappear with it and you’re left with bad credit and less money in your possession. Many companies also claim that they can create a new credit file for you by getting you a “New” Social Security number. This is illegal and never actually works.
- 9/12/2006. Kimbery Credit Counselings Blog
15.41%15. - Divorced? Consolidate Debt

Debt and Divorce

Most divorcing couples have as much debt as they have property. Getting disentangled in divorce is as much about assigning responsibility for the payment of debts as it is dividing up property. Therefore, it is important to:

* Finding out what you owe
* Freeze your debt
* Discuss and allocate responsibility
* Living reasonably with your debt

Finding Out What You Owe

You may already know what is owed since most couples do. Howev - 10/3/2006. Kimbery Credit Counselings Blog
13.31%16.Prohibited Debt Collection Practices -


Debt collectors often use harassing, abusive, false, and/or misleading tactics to attempt to collect on an alleged debt. While the list of prohibited practices is extensive, following are those most commonly committed.



Debt collectors may NOT contact you:


  • At any unusual time or place before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m.

  • After he/she is aware that you are represented by an attorney

  • At your place of employment if your employer prohibits such communications

  • A
- 4/16/2007. Jeff's Blog
12.58%17.Tina's Personal Credit Story! -

I would like to share my own
personal story with you. Maybe it
will be helpful to someone.



I was a bit of an
irresponsible young adult. I
obtained some credit cards right out of high school as I began business school,
and shortly thereafter a vehicle loan for a sporty little Eagle Talon.

- 6/19/2008. Jeff's Blog
12.35%18."Rehabilitation:" What Debt Collectors Don't Want You To Know - Defaulting on your student loans doesn?t exactly put you in rare company.

Despite our best efforts, many of us don?t immediately land that high paying dream job right out of college. And considering that most of us have to deal with immediate concerns such as rent, health insurance or car payments, paying for your student loans seems like a secondary concern.

But make no mistake about it: Student loans are almost just like any other debt, and getting behind on your payments can result in the whole loan being handed over to bill collectors.

As you - 8/23/2007. Jeff's Blog
11.36%19. - Identity Theft - Their Opportunities Are Your Everyday Transactions

In the course of a busy day, you may write a check at the grocery store, charge tickets to a ball game, rent a car, mail your tax returns, call home on your cell phone, order new checks or apply for a credit card. Chances are you don't give these everyday transactions a second thought. But someone else may.

Click here for your free debt consolidation quote now!

The 1990's spawned a new vari - 10/17/2006. Kimbery Credit Counselings Blog